Your physical location is your foundation. But if it’s your only sales channel, you’re leaving money on the table every single day your doors are closed. Adding an online store to your brick-and-mortar business doesn’t have to be complicated, expensive, or overwhelming. It’s one of the smartest moves you can make, and the playbook is more straightforward than most business owners think.

Why Brick-and-Mortar Owners Resist Going Online (And Why Those Reasons Don’t Hold Up)

Most business owners who haven’t added an online store fall into one of three camps. They think it’s too expensive, too technical, or that their customers just aren’t “online shoppers.” Let’s deal with each of these head-on.

Too expensive? Shopify’s basic plan runs $39 per month. WooCommerce (built on WordPress) is free to install. Square Online lets you list products and take payments for free. The entry cost is lower than a single newspaper ad.

Too technical? Every major e-commerce platform today is built for non-technical users. If you can send an email and upload a photo, you can build a basic online store in an afternoon.

Your customers aren’t online? According to the U.S. Census Bureau, e-commerce sales represent a growing share of total retail every single quarter. Even customers who prefer shopping in person use the internet to browse, compare, and decide before they walk through your door.

Step 1: Decide What You’re Selling Online

You don’t have to put your entire inventory online on day one. Start by identifying your best candidates for online sales. A good online product has a few characteristics: it’s easy to describe and photograph, it ships well or can be picked up in store, and it has enough margin to absorb transaction fees.

For service businesses, think about what you can package and sell digitally: gift cards, appointment booking, prepaid service packages, or downloadable guides. For product businesses, start with your top 10 or 20 best sellers and expand from there.

Step 2: Choose Your Platform

The platform you choose depends on what you already use and how complex your needs are. Here’s a plain-English breakdown of the main options:

• Shopify: Best for product-heavy stores that want everything in one place. Easy to set up, tons of apps, and excellent customer support. Works for both online-only and hybrid physical/online setups.
• Square Online: If you already use Square for in-person payments, this is a natural extension. Your inventory syncs automatically between your POS and your online store.
• WooCommerce: Best if you already have a WordPress website. More flexible and customizable than Shopify, but requires slightly more technical comfort.
• BigCommerce: Good for businesses with large catalogs or complex product variants. More enterprise-friendly than Shopify at scale.
• Etsy or Amazon: If you sell handmade, vintage, or niche products, these marketplaces give you a built-in audience. The trade-off is less control and more competition.

For most small brick-and-mortar businesses, Shopify or Square Online is the easiest starting point. If you already use Square for in-person sales, Square Online is a no-brainer because your inventory stays synced across both channels automatically.

Step 3: Set Up Your Store the Right Way

Good product photography is the single biggest factor in whether an online store converts browsers into buyers. You don’t need a professional studio. A white or neutral background, natural light, and a modern smartphone camera will get you 90% of the way there. Take multiple angles, show the product in use, and keep your photos consistent in size and style.

Write product descriptions that answer the questions your customers actually ask in store. What’s it made of? How big is it? What problem does it solve? Skip the marketing fluff and get specific. Specific descriptions reduce returns and build trust.

Price your products to cover your e-commerce costs. Factor in payment processing fees (typically 2.5 to 3%), packaging, and your time. If you’re offering free shipping, build that cost into your prices. Customers who see unexpected shipping charges at checkout abandon their carts at high rates.

Step 4: Handle Fulfillment Without Losing Your Mind

Fulfillment is where a lot of first-time online sellers get overwhelmed. Keep it simple at the start. For most small businesses, you have three options:

• Ship it yourself: Buy a postal scale, open a business account with USPS, UPS, or FedEx, and ship from your location. This works fine for low order volumes and gives you full control over the customer experience.
• Local pickup: Let customers order online and pick up in store. This drives foot traffic, eliminates shipping costs, and often leads to additional purchases when they come in. It’s also a great option for heavy, fragile, or high-value items.
• Offer both: Give customers the choice and let demand tell you which is more popular in your market.

Don’t over-engineer this at the start. Get your first 50 orders under your belt before you start worrying about automation or third-party logistics. Learning the basics yourself also helps you make better decisions when you’re ready to scale.

Step 5: Drive Traffic to Your New Store

Building a store is step one. Getting people to it is the ongoing work. Here’s how brick-and-mortar owners have a natural advantage: you already have customers. Use that.

Tell your in-store customers the store exists. Put a sign at the register. Add a card to every bag. Send a text blast or email to your customer list announcing the launch. Offer a small discount for first online orders to incentivize your regulars to try it.

Optimize for local search. Make sure your Google Business Profile links to your online store. Use your city and neighborhood in your product descriptions and page titles where it’s natural. Customers who search for products “near me” may land on your site even if they’ve never heard of your business before. For a deeper dive on capturing local search traffic, check out our guide on how to use your Google Business Profile to get more local customers.

Use social media to show products in action. Short videos of products, behind-the-scenes packaging content, and “new arrival” posts are cheap and effective. You don’t need a following to start; you need consistency. Our guide on using Instagram to grow your small business covers the playbook in detail.

Step 6: Connect Your Online and Offline Operations

One of the biggest operational challenges when adding an online store is keeping inventory accurate across both channels. Nothing kills customer trust faster than selling something online that you don’t actually have in stock.

If you’re using Square, Shopify, or Lightspeed as your point-of-sale system, they all offer inventory sync between in-person and online sales. Set this up from day one. If you’re running separate systems, you’ll need to build a manual reconciliation habit or use a middleware tool to keep counts consistent.

Set a par level for any product you sell both in-store and online. When inventory drops below that level, pause online sales for that item until you restock. Better to show “temporarily out of stock” than to oversell and disappoint a customer.

Step 7: Track What’s Working and Adjust

Your online store generates data your physical store never could. You can see exactly which products customers look at, which ones they add to their cart and then abandon, and which pages they leave from. That information is gold.

Set up Google Analytics on your store from day one. Check it weekly in the first few months. Look for your top traffic sources, your best-converting products, and your cart abandonment rate. If your abandonment rate is above 70%, your checkout process has friction. If traffic is high but conversions are low, your product pages need work.

Don’t try to fix everything at once. Pick one metric to improve each month and run experiments until it moves. Small consistent improvements compound quickly. Our guide on marketing your small business on a tight budget has additional tactics for getting more out of every dollar you spend.

The Real Payoff: A Business That Works Around the Clock

When you add an online store to a brick-and-mortar business, you’re not just adding a sales channel. You’re making your business available to customers 24 hours a day, seven days a week, 365 days a year. Your physical location has closing hours. Your online store doesn’t.

That’s revenue generated while you sleep. It’s customers in other zip codes who would never have found you otherwise. It’s a buffer against slow foot-traffic days and a hedge against anything that closes your doors temporarily. The businesses that survived the disruptions of the early 2020s weren’t necessarily the biggest ones. They were the ones with multiple ways to reach and sell to customers.

You don’t need to build an Amazon. You need to build a reliable second revenue channel that complements what you already do well in person. Start small, learn fast, and grow from there.

---

Ready to level up your business knowledge? Join thousands of entrepreneurs who get practical, no-BS business guides every week. Join Hustler’s Library for free and get the tools and insights you need to grow.