A new survey of 501 small business owners — commissioned by business insurance platform Next Insurance and released this week — reveals a striking contradiction at the heart of American entrepreneurship: more business owners are buying insurance, but the majority are still dangerously underprotected. According to the report, 82% of businesses in their first year of operation carry insurance. Yet across all small businesses, 73% are either uninsured or underinsured for the risks they actually face.
The headline number sounds reassuring. The full picture is not.
What This Actually Means
Here’s the gap: buying a policy and having the right coverage are two completely different things. According to the Next Insurance report, 64% of insured small businesses say they’re not covered for all major risks — and 14% of those owners aren’t even sure what their current policy covers. An additional 25% of small businesses carry no insurance at all.
The reasons are predictable. Fifty percent of uninsured owners say insurance is too expensive. Twenty percent say it’s too confusing. And when you’re a small business owner watching your cash flow like a hawk, coverage beyond the bare legal minimum can feel like a luxury line item.
It isn’t.
The Numbers Behind It
The report’s findings land differently when you put them in context:
- There are 33.2 million small businesses in the United States, according to the SBA. If 73% of those are underinsured, that’s more than 24 million businesses exposed to potentially company-ending financial events.
- The report found that 37% of small business owners cite maintaining steady cash flow as a top source of stress — which is exactly the kind of pressure that leads owners to skip or minimize coverage.
- Separately, 33% of entrepreneurs say they worry about their business closing on a weekly basis, per Next Insurance’s own risk survey. Underinsurance is a direct contributor to that anxiety: one liability claim, one property fire, one cyber attack can wipe out a business with no financial safety net.
The Federal Reserve’s 2025 Small Business Credit Survey corroborates the broader financial strain: 43% of small business owners work more than 60 hours per week. When you’re that stretched, insurance audits fall to the bottom of the list. The data says that’s a mistake small businesses can’t afford to keep making.
The Hustler’s Library Take
This report is a gut-check disguised as a survey.
The fact that first-year businesses are more likely to be insured than businesses in years two through five tells you something important: early-stage founders are taking protection seriously, then losing that discipline as operations get busier and costs pile up. That’s backwards. Workplace injuries, liability claims, and operational disruptions don’t happen on year one — they happen when you scale, hire, and take on more risk.
The “too expensive” excuse deserves scrutiny too. Business insurance for most small operations runs a few hundred to a couple thousand dollars a year. A single uninsured liability event can cost ten times that. This isn’t a cost problem. It’s a priority problem. And the entrepreneurs who treat it like a priority are the ones still operating five years from now.
The good news: digital-first insurance platforms have made comparison and purchase faster than ever. There is no longer a logistical excuse for not knowing what you’re covered for. The only excuse left is inaction — and that one is on you.
What You Should Do
This report isn’t abstract. Here are three concrete moves to make this week:
- Schedule a coverage audit. Pull out your current policy and go line by line. Does it cover cyber liability? General liability? Business interruption? If you don’t know, that’s your answer. Call your provider and ask them to walk you through it. If they can’t, you need a better provider.
- Run a risk inventory for your business. Think through your three biggest exposure points: customer-facing interactions, physical assets, and digital operations. Cross-reference those against your current coverage. Understand your competitive risk environment — industry-specific risks (food service, construction, professional services) often require riders your general policy won’t include.
- Separate “legally required” from “actually protected.” Many states mandate a minimum level of general liability or workers’ comp. Meeting the minimum is not the same as being protected. If a customer slips and sues for $500,000, does your policy cover that? Find out before it matters.
The 82% of year-one businesses getting insured immediately is genuinely good news. But the story this report tells is really about what happens next: the slow erosion of protection as the business matures and attention shifts elsewhere. Don’t let that be your story.
Want more straight talk on running a smarter business? Join Hustler’s Library free and get the resources serious entrepreneurs actually use.
Ready to Know Where You Stand?
The Business Journey dashboard maps your exact position across all 13 stages. Track your progress, unlock resources for each step, and build with a framework used by thousands of founders at Hustler's Library.
No credit card required · Takes 3 minutes · Personalized to your stage
